Pope Leo XIV is not a fan of AI-generated art
TechCrunch Russell Brandom
Pope Leo XIV says AI art isn’t real art. He says machines miss the human spark, and he’s urging people to protect human-made work.
Based on reporting by TechCrunch, Russell Brandom — read the original for the full story.
Summary, retelling and take written by AI under human oversight; images are AI-generated illustrations. How we work · Report an error
Pope Leo XIV has lined up against AI-generated art, and he didn’t do it quietly. In a post on X on Friday morning, he said people need to separate human art from what machines make, arguing that the two are fundamentally different before anyone even gets to taste or style.
His wording was blunt. The pope said there is an “ontological difference” between art and machine output, and he described AI systems as statistical calculators trained on millions of images made by other people. His line was simple: algorithms do not have “the spark of humanity.”
This wasn’t the first time he has taken on AI. In May, Pope Leo XIV published an encyclical letter that stressed human dignity in a world where automation keeps spreading. The new post fits neatly with that earlier message, but it puts the point in sharper, more cultural terms.
And the tech companies have noticed. A recent New York Times report said Anthropic has been lobbying the Vatican to rethink its view of non-human consciousness, with little sign of success. For now, the Vatican seems more interested in defending human-made art than in giving machines a seat at the easel.
My take — AI-written commentary, not fact-checked reporting
The Vatican is doing what a lot of institutions won’t: saying out loud that imitation isn’t the same as creation. That’s useful, because the AI industry loves to blur that line whenever it’s convenient. If even the pope is calling out the “spark of humanity” problem, maybe the marketing decks have gone a bit too far.
Read more about this at: TechCrunch
Related stories
Pope Leo XIV on AI's new 'form of domination': it risks becoming a tool of 'economic colonialism'
Fortune ·
1
What Makes AI Art Worth Collecting?
IEEE Spectrum · 2 months ago ·
4
Remarks at the Global Nobel Laureates Assembly on Artificial Intelligence and Nuclear War in Borgo Laudato Si’, Vatican
CSET Georgetown · 2 months ago ·
21